Why Mini Ice Cream Sandwiches Are Great
Bite‑sized and adorable — perfect for parties, kids, or casual snacks.
Customizable — cookies, ice cream flavor, coatings, mix‑ins.
No oven required if using store‑bought cookies (semi no‑bake).
Fun to assemble and great for letting people pick their favorite combos.
Portable and easy to freeze/serve.
I’ll start with a “base master recipe,” then walk through many options and tips to elevate it.
Core Ingredients & Equipment
Ingredients (Base Version — yields ~12 mini sandwiches)
Component Amount Notes / suggestions
Cookies or small sandwich cookies / wafer cookies 24 (or equivalent) Eg: vanilla wafers, sugar cookies, chocolate cookies — your choice
Ice cream (or gelato or frozen yogurt) ~1 to 1½ cups Slightly softened before assembly
Chocolate (for coating or roll) ~1 oz, chopped Dark, semi‑sweet, or milk — optional
Optional: mix-ins / flavoring e.g. chopped nuts, sprinkles, crushed cookies, chocolate chips For rolling edges or mixing into ice cream
Equipment
Shallow storage container or baking sheet
Wax paper or parchment (to line)
Small scoop or teaspoon for portioning ice cream
Knife or small spatula
Freezer
Bowls or small dishes for coatings
Optional: cookie cutter if using larger cookies and cutting shapes
Step‑by‑Step Instructions
Below is a detailed workflow, including reasons behind each step.
Step 1: Prepare & Soften the Ice Cream
Remove the ice cream from the freezer ~5–10 minutes before assembly so it softens slightly but is not melting. You want it pliable, not liquid.
If it’s too firm, scooping will crack cookies; too soft and it will ooze out. A balance is key.
Step 2: Line Your Container
Line a shallow container or baking sheet with wax paper or parchment. This prevents sticking and helps with freezing/handling later.
You’ll place assembled sandwiches here for final freeze.
Step 3: Portion Ice Cream & Assemble
Take half of your cookies (e.g. 12 if you have 24).
Scoop a small amount (e.g. ~1 tablespoon or 2 teaspoons, depending on cookie size) of softened ice cream onto the flat side of each cookie.
Top with the remaining cookies, flat side down, to form a sandwich. Press gently but firmly to spread the ice cream evenly to the edges (but do not smash too hard).
If edges are rough, you can even them with a small spatula or clean finger.
Step 4: Optional Coating or Roll Edges
Place your chopped chocolate, nuts, sprinkles, crushed cookies, or chips in a shallow dish.
Carefully roll the edges of each sandwich in the chosen coating so that it sticks to the ice cream sides. This adds texture and looks pretty.
For chocolate coating: melt chocolate gently (e.g. microwave in short bursts or double boiler), dip or drizzle over the sandwich edges.
Step 5: Freeze to Set
Transfer assembled sandwiches to the lined container, in a single layer.
Freeze for at least 30 minutes to 1 hour (or longer) so the ice cream firms and the sandwiches hold shape.
After set, you can stack them (with parchment between) and store in an airtight container or freezer bag.
Tips & Tricks for Perfect Mini Ice Cream Sandwiches
Cookie choice matters: Use cookies that are sturdy but not rock-hard. Vanilla wafers, butter cookies, chocolate sandwich cookies, sugar cookies, or even homemade cookies are good.
Uniform size: Pick cookie pairs that match in size so the sandwiches look neat.
Ice cream consistency: Ice cream should be soft enough to scoop but still chilled. If melted, it will leak; if too hard, you’ll crack cookies.
Edge coating helps: Rolling edges in chocolate or sprinkles helps hide imperfections and adds a decorative touch.
Work quickly: Ice cream will warm and melt, so assemble quickly and return to freezer.
Press gently: Press top cookie down just enough to spread ice cream, but not so much that it bulges overly.
Freezer space: Make sure your freezer is sufficiently cold and space is available so sandwiches don’t get jostled.
Variations & Flavor Ideas
Here are many creative spins to try:
1. PB & J Mini Ice Cream Sandwiches
Use vanilla wafers, spread a thin layer of peanut butter and strawberry or raspberry jam on one cookie before adding ice cream, then sandwich. (From Laura Fuentes recipe)
Laura Fuentes
2. Tiny Cookie‑Ice Cream Sandwiches
Use small scoop cookies or mini cookies, scoop ice cream, sandwich, roll edges in chocolate chips or chopped nuts. (From Food Network Tiny Ice Cream Sandwiches)
Food Network
3. Waffle Mini Sandwiches
Use mini waffles instead of cookies. Toast waffles first, cool, then sandwich ice cream, press, roll edges in sprinkles if desired. (Eggo Minis variation)
leggomyeggo.com
4. Ice Cream with Swirls or Mix-ins
Use flavored ice cream (chocolate, mint, strawberry), or fold in bits of fruit, chocolate chips, cookie crumbs before scooping.
For example, Crunchmaster has a strawberry shortcake mini ice cream sandwich version.
crunchmaster.com
5. No‑Bake / Mini‑Batch
Make your own cookie base (oat flour, etc.), layer ice cream, freeze, slice into mini sandwiches. (Mini-batch no-bake technique)
minibatchbaker.com
6. Thin Mint Style / Themed Sandwiches
Use thin mint cookies or other branded cookies for themed treats. (Hallmark Thin Mint version)
Hallmark Channel
7. Ice Cream Sandwich Cake / Layered Version
Stack mini sandwiches with whipped cream or frosting layers for a decorative dessert cake. (Mentioned in discussion of ice cream sandwich cakes)
Southern Living
Storage & Serving
Store mini ice cream sandwiches in an airtight container or freezer bag. Use parchment paper between layers to prevent sticking.
They keep well for up to a week (or more, depending on ice cream quality).
Serve directly from freezer. Let sit a minute or two if very cold so they’re easier to bite.
For plate presentation, you can garnish with chocolate drizzle, fresh fruit, mint leaves, or edible flowers.
Full Recipe Recap (Printable Format)
Mini Ice Cream Sandwiches
Yields: ~12 mini sandwiches (depending on cookie size)
Prep time: ~15 minutes (plus freeze time)
Freeze / set time: 30–60 minutes
Ingredients
24 cookies (e.g. vanilla wafers, sugar cookies, chocolate cookies)
~1 to 1½ cups ice cream (flavor of choice), slightly softened
1 oz chocolate, finely chopped (for coating)
Optional coatings: chopped nuts, sprinkles, cookie crumbs
Optional mix-ins: bits of chocolate, fruit, cookie crumbs in ice cream
Instructions
Line a tray with wax or parchment.
Scoop a small portion of softened ice cream (~1 tbsp or 2 tsp, depending on cookie) onto half of the cookies.
Top with second cookie, press gently to spread ice cream evenly.
Roll edges in chocolate or other coating so it sticks to the ice cream side.
Place sandwiches in tray.
Freeze for at least 30 minutes (or until firm).
Store in airtight container, use parchment layers between.
Serve cold, let sit briefly if very frozen before eating.
If you like, I can convert this into a metric version (grams, mL) or customize a flavor combo (chocolate lovers, exotic fruits, etc.) and send you a printable card. Do you want me to do that for you?
0 comments:
Post a Comment