Grandma’s Old‑Fashioned Fudge – A Recipe You Can’t Lose! 🍫
This is the kind of fudge that Grandma might have made: simple ingredients, affectionate care, and a texture that melts in the mouth. If you follow the method, control the temperature, stir at the right times, you’ll get fudge that’s creamy, not grainy, firm but not stiff. Let’s go.
Ingredients & Why They Matter
Ingredient Amount* Role / Tip
Granulated sugar ~ 3 cups (≈ 600‑650 g) The main sweetener. Needs to dissolve completely before heating hard.
Unsalted butter ~ ½ cup (≈ 113 g) Adds richness, fat gives smooth mouthfeel. Unsalted lets you control salt.
Evaporated milk or whole milk (or mixture) ~ 1 cup (≈ 240 ml) evaporated milk or milk + small cream Evaporated milk helps with firmness and creaminess; whole milk or milk + cream version gives richer taste. Sometimes a recipe uses both.
Corn syrup or light syrup / optional small amount (e.g. 2 Tbsp) Helps prevent sugar crystallization; keeps fudge smoother and more forgiving. Optional in some “classic” versions.
Marshmallow crème / mini marshmallows / fluff (optional) ~ ½ jar / 5‑7 oz or ~ 1 cup small marshmallows Adds creaminess, helps texture; a shortcut often used in more modern “Grandma fudge” recipes.
Vanilla extract ~ 1 teaspoon Flavor—classic fudge needs that vanilla note.
Salt pinch (¼‑½ tsp) Enhances flavor; cuts sweetness a bit; optional but helps balance.
Optional add‑ins: nuts (walnuts, pecans), chocolate chips, white chocolate, butter extract, etc. ~ ½ to 1 cup chopped Adds texture & variation; fold in at end.
*These amounts are for a standard batch, making about a 9×9 inch or 8×8 inch pan of fudge (≈ 24‑36 pieces depending on size). You can scale up or down, but maintain proportions and especially pay attention to temperature and timing.
Equipment You’ll Need
Heavy‑bottomed saucepan (to distribute heat evenly, avoid hotspots)
Candy thermometer (very helpful; soft ball stage is key)
Wooden spoon (or heat‑proof silicone / heavy spoon)
Spatula for spreading
Baking pan (8×8 or 9×9 inches, or similar) lined with foil or parchment, greased or buttered
Butter or non‑stick spray for pan
Knife for cutting fudge
(Optional) Cooling rack, timer, and a bowl of cold water for testing sugar stage if no thermometer
Key Concepts & Why Fudge Fails
Understanding these helps avoid common pitfalls:
Soft Ball Stage — When the sugar syrup reaches about 234‑240°F (≈ 112‑116°C), it forms a soft ball in cold water. This is critical. If you remove too early, fudge won’t set; too late → too hard.
Allrecipes
+2
Sustainable Cooks
+2
Dissolving Sugar & Avoiding Crystallization — Ensure all sugar is dissolved before boiling; don’t scrape the sides where sugar crystals can form. Use syrup or corn syrup or marshmallow creme to help reduce risk.
Sustainable Cooks
+1
Cooling Without Disturbance — Once you’ve cooked and removed from heat, let the mixture cool undisturbed to around ~110°F (≈ 43‑45°C), then beat. Beating too early → grainy or crystallized fudge.
americastestkitchen.com
+1
Beating / Stirring at Right Time — After cooling, stir until the fudge loses gloss (shine), becomes somewhat matte, thickens. That’s when it’s ready to go into the pan.
Sustainable Cooks
+2
Chef Lindsey Farr
+2
Step‑By‑Step Instructions
Here is the full process, very detailed, so you can’t go wrong.
Step 1: Prep Everything First
Measure all ingredients in advance. Make sure your pan is lined and greased. If using nuts or add‑ins, chop them, toast if desired, have them ready.
If you use marshmallow crème or mini marshmallows, measure that too.
Arrange tools: thermometer, spoon, spatula ready.
Step 2: Combine & Heat
In the heavy saucepan, melt the butter over low to medium heat.
Add sugar and evaporated milk (or milk/cream + syrup, as your recipe variant). Stir gently, dissolving sugar fully. Make sure mixture is smooth, no grainy sugar at bottom or sides. If sugar clings to sides, use a wet pastry brush to wash down the sugar so it dissolves rather than crystallizes.
Instructables
+1
Once sugar is fully dissolved, increase heat (but not too high) until mixture comes to a rolling boil. Be ready with the thermometer or water‑test. Boil for the needed time until it reaches the soft ball stage (≈ 234‑240°F / 112‑116°C) depending on recipe. Some recipes call for holding the boil for a set time (e.g. 4 minutes) once boiled.
Sustainable Cooks
+2
americastestkitchen.com
+2
Step 3: Remove from Heat & Add Flavorings
As soon as the fudge mixture reaches the soft ball stage, remove it from heat. If using marshmallow crème or chips, chocolate chips, add them now, plus vanilla and salt. Stir until everything is well melted and combined.
Stir gently until mixture begins to lose its gloss (shine). It should thicken and become more matte. This signals the right point to pour into the pan. If it still looks very shiny and fluid, wait a little, or gently stir until texture starts changing.
Allrecipes
+2
Sustainable Cooks
+2
Step 4: Pour & Set
Pour the fudge into the prepared pan, smoothing the top with a spatula. If you are using nuts or add‑ins, fold in before pouring. If you want nut halves on top for decoration, press them in after pouring.
Let it set at room temperature for some time. Depending on recipe, it may need ~30‑60 minutes, or up to a few hours. Some folks leave overnight. Do not refrigerate immediately; cooling too fast can affect texture. On humid days, room temperature matters.
Sustainable Cooks
+1
Once set sufficiently (firm to touch but still yielding a bit), cut into squares. Clean knife helps—dipping in hot water, wiping dry between cuts helps get clean edges.
Timing Guide
Phase Approx Time*
Prep (measure, line pan, prepare add‑ins) 10 minutes
Heating & boiling to soft ball stage ~ 8‑12 minutes (depends on stove, pan, amount)
Flavor addition & stirring until gloss is gone 2‑5 minutes
Setting at room temperature ~ 30‑90 minutes (or more)
Total time ~ 1 hour 15 minutes to 2 hours (depending on size, cooling time)
*Times can vary depending on batch size, altitude, humidity, etc.
Variations & Flavor Twists
To make Grandma’s fudge your own, or adapt when you don’t have exactly classic ingredients, try these:
Nutty fudge: walnuts, pecans, almonds folded in. Toasting them first adds flavor.
Chocolate & marshmallow fudge: use chocolate chips + marshmallow crème or fluff + vanilla. Many “modern old‑fudge” recipes do this.
Sustainable Cooks
+2
Grandma's Recipes
+2
Vanilla & spice fudge: use white chocolate or reduce cocoa; add vanilla extract + maybe ground spices like cinnamon, nutmeg, even ginger. Good for seasonal versions.
Flavored extracts: peppermint, almond, coffee, etc. Add at end with vanilla.
Swirl versions: peanut butter swirl, caramel swirl, chocolate swirl. Add after removing from heat and before setting.
Holiday specials: add crushed candy cane, colored sugar sprinkles, bits of toffee, etc.
Troubleshooting & “What Ifs”
Problem Likely Cause What You Can Do
Fudge comes out grainy Sugar crystallized (from sides; scraping; sugar not fully dissolved; stirred too much or too early) Make sure sugar dissolves completely; avoid stirring during boil; use syrup or marshmallow or corn syrup helps; do not scrape sides; use clean utensils.
Fudge doesn’t set (too soft) Didn’t reach soft ball stage; too much liquid; evaporated milk / cream content too high; cooking not long enough Use a candy thermometer; cook until correct temperature; reduce liquid slightly; test via cold water test; ensure pan and mixture size are suitable.
Fudge too hard / brittle Overcooked; boiled past ideal stage; too little moisture or fat; stirred too long after gloss loss Watch temperature carefully; remove at correct soft ball; use proper butter/fat; don’t over‑beat; adjust recipe slightly for your stove / pan.
Top forms crust / skin or becomes too slippery Cooling too slowly; leaving uncovered; humidity Cover loosely with plastic wrap after some time; cool in moderately cool room; avoid drafts or high humidity; sometimes tent with foil.
Burned bottom or burning at edges Heat too high; pan too thin; insufficient stirring early on (sugar settles and burns) Use moderate heat; heavy bottomed saucepan; stir gently at early heating; avoid direct high flame; use double boiler style if needed.
Storage & Serving
Once cut, fudge kept in an airtight container. If stacking layers, separate with wax or parchment paper so they don’t stick.
Room temperature is fine for several days (4‑7 days) if in cool place. If warm or humid environment, refrigerate.
It generally keeps well in fridge for ~2 weeks. For longer storage, freeze in wrapped squares—thaw at room temperature before serving.
For gifting, wrap individual squares in wax or parchment, put in decorative box or cellophane.
Full Example Recipe (Detailed)
Here is a full, “one you can trust” recipe:
Grandma’s Old‑Fashioned Fudge
Yields: ~36 squares (in a 9×9 or 8×8 inch pan)
Ingredients:
3 cups granulated sugar
½ cup (1 stick) unsalted butter (≈ 113 g), plus a bit more to butter the pan
1 cup evaporated milk (≈ 240 ml)
1‑2 Tbsp light corn syrup (optional, helps smoothness)
½ jar marshmallow crème or ~1 cup mini marshmallows (optional but helpful)
1 tsp pure vanilla extract
Pinch of salt (¼‑½ tsp)
½ to 1 cup chopped nuts (walnuts or pecans) optional
Instructions:
Line an 8×8 or 9×9 pan with foil or parchment paper, allowing extra hanging over sides. Butter or grease well.
In heavy saucepan, melt butter over low heat. Add sugar and evaporated milk (and corn syrup if using). Stir until sugar is fully dissolved.
Increase heat to medium. Bring mixture to rolling boil, stirring constantly early so sugar doesn’t stick or burn. Use candy thermometer or test with cold water. When mixture reaches ~234‑240°F (soft ball stage), maintain rolling boil for short bit (1‑3 minutes) depending on stove, being cautious.
Remove from heat. If using marshmallow crème / marshmallows, add now, plus vanilla and salt. Stir until melted and mixture is smooth.
Let mixture cool undisturbed for a bit (until temp ~110°F / feels cooler; mixture starts losing shine). Then beat with wooden spoon or spatula until mixture becomes matte, thick, a bit drop‑away from sides. This may take a few minutes.
Fold in nuts if using.
Pour into prepared pan, smooth top lightly. Press nuts on top if desired.
Let set at room temperature (30‑90 minutes or longer). Once firm, cut into squares with a sharp knife. Clean knife between cuts if sticky.
“Why This Recipe You Can’t Lose”
Uses reliable, simple ingredients that are widely available.
The soft ball stage guideline & thermometer or water test gives precise control.
Incorporates options (marshmallows, corn syrup) that make the fudge more forgiving.
Cooling & beating method prevents common problems like graininess.
Share / (c.o.m.m.e.n.t) Version
Use this if you want to drop a quick version into comments or messages.
(c.o.m.m.e.n.t)
Grandma’s Old Fashioned Fudge – Foolproof Recipe
Ingredients:
‑ 3 cups granulated sugar
‑ ½ cup unsalted butter
‑ 1 cup evaporated milk
‑ 1‑2 Tbsp corn syrup (optional, helps texture)
‑ ½ jar marshmallow crème or ~1 cup mini marshmallows (optional)
‑ 1 tsp vanilla extract
‑ Pinch salt
‑ ½‑1 cup chopped nuts (walnuts or pecans) optional
Instructions:
1. Line and butter an 8×8 or 9×9 pan.
2. In heavy saucepan: melt butter, add sugar + evaporated milk (+ syrup). Stir until sugar dissolves.
3. Bring to a rolling boil over medium heat; with thermometer (or water test), cook until soft ball stage (~234‑240°F / 112‑116°C).
4. Remove from heat; stir in marshmallow / vanilla / salt; mix until smooth.
5. Let mixture cool undisturbed until it starts losing gloss (≈ 110°F), then beat until thick and matte.
6. Fold in nuts if using, pour into prepared pan, smooth top.
7. Let set at room temperature until firm, then cut into squares.
You’ll get creamy, classic fudge every time—rich, smooth, melt‑in‑your‑mouth.
(/c.o.m.m.e.n.t)
If you like, I can translate this recipe into metric/imperial exactly for your kitchen, or adapt it with local flavors (e.g. using dates, honey, or regional nuts). Do you want that version too?
0 comments:
Post a Comment